Let's keep things simple and ONLY provide results on attractiveness, which is what our "literature" directed us toward.  You should tell the reader that the data on the other factors were collected but also tell the reader that those data will not be reported on in the paper you're writing.

The reader will expect to hear something about the reliability of the measure you're reporting on.  To do this, you'll run an SPSS feature that will calculate and average all possible split half correlations between the observers' evaluations of whatever facial measurement you're interested in.  The result of this averaging as an Alpha value that you should use in the same way Dr. Baril told you to use Alpha in lecture.  You should seperately report Alpha values for males and females on attractiveness and tell the reader if the correlations are strong enough, based upon established norms that Dr. Baril discussed in class.

Here's how you execute the SPSS function.  Click on:  Analyze - Scale - Reliability Analyses (Now doesn't that sound like what you want to do??)  Once you're in Reliability Analysis (Don't ask me why it's singular once you're in it, but that's what it says.), you can just pound in the variables from your observers that relate to the facial aspect you're looking for a reliability estimate on.  Once the variables are in, of course, you should Paste and then run the syntax.  Like magic, you'll have an Alpha level for observations on the issue at hand. 

Then the reader will expect the male/female correlation on attractiveness and means/standard deviations on the male/female attractiveness scores.  I think the paper will be improved by including a figure to show the nice correlation you have here.  So, stick in a scattergram, following APA guidelines for insertion and format.  You may use SPSS to create this figure, but try to match APA formatting guidelines.

When you are dealing with SPSS for the multiple observers, you could work with syntax and just type in "mat_1 mat_2" and so on, for example.  When you are typing in variables by hand like this, you don't have to worry about listing them in syntax in any particular order.

These photos were found by searching the internet for engagement or wedding photos that showed both members of a couple.  In no way was this a "random" sample.  The photos were then edited to separate the heads of the male and female.  Also remember that the reader will want to know about who collected these data as well.